Thursday, October 28, 2010
The project continues...
Zoonotic diseases vary from area to area due to many circumstances including climate, population density (I.e. diseases carried by white tail deer are not typically found in heavily populated cities), native species of wildlife, the level of agriculture in a given area, and the financial stability of an area (I.e. people financially stable travel more frequently, including out the country, exposing them to zoonotic disease). I called the licensing board for the State of California to inquire about having a contact list of small animal veterinarians. I was told I needed to fax a letter with my intent and their legal department would determine if they could release the information to me. I did so really expecting to hear they would release the information to me, since I was only asking for contact information, the same information a pet owner could acquire when looking for veterinary assistance. I was told they could not release that information to me....so, I no longer included California in my study.
Since the spring I also added a subtopic of what other countries, such as the UK, are doing...are they encouraging communication between both medical profession and if so, how? I would like to be able to compare and contrast where our medical think we are at to what another country, similar to our own, is at.
If you've been following to see how things are going, stay tuned...over the next couple of weeks there will be more to say....
Thursday, March 25, 2010
Unexpected complication
How would that help me?
The focus of my capstone project is small animal veterinarians and family physicians; a list already determining all of the licensed small animal veterinarians in a state would reduce my additional steps of looking up every potential contributor to my capstone online to determine their primary patient species. Its not impossible, just incredibly tedious.
To get back to California...
When I spoke to the office of the veterinary medical board I came to one of my first official stand stills, they wanted me to fax them the jest of my capstone study. I immediately sent out the following statement...
Florida, California, Texas, and New York are the states in my study and are the best representation of the continental United States due to their climates, ecological factors, and economic standings all of which can influence the types of zoonotic diseases seen in each area3. Each states sample is determined by the states provided current licensed and practicing family physicians and small animal veterinarians. I am sending a request to complete my survey provided by a link through www.surveymonkey.com to a random 150 professionals from each profession in each state, ultimately requesting voluntary participation from 600 small animal veterinarians and 600 family practice physicians. In addition to the request for completing a survey, I am asking for participation in phone interviews and a web forum. The electronic survey will collect general information on the communication efforts between veterinarians and family practice physicians. However, the phone interview will provides specific viewpoints from the professional and a web forum will be offer a means for professionals to give a viewpoint in real time in an environment similar to that of brainstorming. Analyzed data provided by the electronic survey is anonymous, the phone interview may or may not be anonymous, and the web forum will not be anonymous. The consent form indicates the anonymity of the phone survey, denotes the lack of anonymity with the phone interview and web forum, and explains that declining involvement in the interview or forum does not affect the results or potential participation in either.
http://vetmedicine.about.com/diseasesall/a/aa051303a.htm
2 Rabinowitz, Peter M, Conti, Lisa A. (2010) Human-Animal Medicine Clinical Approach to Zoonoses, Toxicants and Other Shared Health Risks. Saunders.
Friday, March 5, 2010
I propose...
American Society of Health-System Pharmacists. (2009) Rabies Vaccine. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/bookshelf/br.fcgi?book=meds&log$=drug_bottom_one&part=a607023
/Vol4/antibiotic_resistance_concern_veterinary_human_me.pdf
Center for Disease Control and Prevention. National Center of Zoonotic, Vector-Borne and Enteric Disease. http://www.cdc.gov.ncved/
Immunocompromised Persons: The Role of Physicians and Veterinarians.
http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/eid/vol5no1/grant.htm
Survey Monkey. (2010) http://www.surveymonkey.com
Sunday, February 28, 2010
One step at a time...
I know it has been a long time since I blogged about this project, but I can guarantee it’s not because there’s been a shortage of work… Since last blogging, I’ve accomplished the following:
- Signed up with Survey Monkey©. I created my surveys for both physicians and veterinarians.
- The consent forms have been completed (needing minor tweaking).
- The proposal was completed, however is in the process of complete renovation.
- I’ve narrowed down my sampling. The technique I was previously using has changed (I’ll explain more in a minute).
- I made a description of how I will be analyzing my data.
- I’ve purchased, and have been reading, a few books I think will give me additional information on zoonotic disease, communication between professionals, and communication between health professional and patient.
I have to admit, I cant recall ever working on a project this hard; not that I have never worked hard on a project, I have done data digging and informally researched projects on my own accord to simply discover more information on a particular subject matter. This has been a little intimidating at times.
Originally I was going to seek my sample from four states (Florida, Texas, California, and New York) and three population density locations (rural, suburb, and city) within each of those locations. I was attempting to get information from small animal veterinarians and family physicians that have the same clients (veterinarian)/patient (physician)…essentially looking for an ordered pair. How I was going to achieve this (in my mind anyway) was picking a location on the map as the epicenter for each of those three locations, use a compass measured out (according to the atlas’ key) 60 miles, figuring the average person would drive no greater than 60 miles on average to a physician or veterinarian. However, what I failed to think of was what the average person would drive if they live in a city or suburb, compared to what the average person would drive in a rural location. I live in a rural area in Michigan currently, however I previously lived in a suburb of Detroit (Waterford). Its nothing for someone to drive greater than 40 miles to a physician from the area I live now, however in Waterford the average person lived less than 20 minutes from their physician or veterinarian…this put holes through sampling techniques. Therefore, I’ve revised it to the following…
I still feel it necessary to choose Florida, California, Texas, and New York as my sample states (these states best represent the continental United States and the zoonotic diseases they may encounter), however instead of choosing three population densities, I’m looking at sending requests to 150 potential recipients (300 total, 150 for each health profession). I’m accounting for the population densities by asking each participant to provide the population size at the location of their facility; when I gave it greater thought, if I was to choose my location by population density I am making that a focus or variable of my study, and that is not my intent. However, I do believe it’s necessary to notes differences according to population.
To gather my sample, I looked up the state websites for each of the veterinary licensing boards and physician licensing boards. My plan is to create a database of email addresses for 1200 professionals (150 for each professional, 300 for each state); each name will be chosen at random, choosing every fifth or tenth name on the list of alphabetical professionals. I have run into a problem that will cost me more work with some states…some do not differentiate on their list of the specialty the veterinarian practices (such as small animal). This past week I called the licensing board for each profession at each state. In addition to finding out which professionals are small animal veterinarians, I also was double checking the accuracy of the information provided on their websites (I.e. how current); the endeavor consisted of two days of calling and also faxing the veterinary licensing board in California (so they could verify my intentions and find out through their licensing board and determine if their legal department would allow me to gain additional information from them). Granted the resubmission of my proposal is accepted, I’ll started data collecting on Monday, March 1st.
The survey portion of data collecting will run from March 1st until March 14th. The week of March 15th, I’ll be conducting phone interviews based on the information I collected from the surveys. In addition, a focus group (what I previously referred to as a web conference) will commence during the week of March 22nd. I look forward to getting through the data collection step and begin analyzing the data.
I purchased a few books, as I mentioned above, that I believe will provide additional information and support for my research. The books I purchased include:
- Impact of Emerging Zoonotic Diseases on Animal Health, 8th Biennial Conference of the Society for tropical veterinary medicine (2006). Although you may be reading this and thinking “doesn’t that say for tropical veterinary medicine,” trust me, there is very relevant information in this book; an example include “Linking Human and Animal Health Surveillance for Emerging Diseases in the United States (Lynn, Marano, Treadwell, Bokma, 2006).”
- Human-Animal Medicine Clinical Approaches to Zoonoses, Toxicants and Other Shared Health Risks (Rabinowitz, Conti, 2010). This is a wonderful book I would recommend to any veterinary or health professional that comes into contact with any kind of zoonotic diseases either through patients/clients or themselves. The information covered in this text is proving to be invaluable to my research project, but it also is going to be invaluable as a Licensed Veterinary Technician.
- Health Professional and Patient Interaction (Purtilo, Haddad, 1996). The purchase of this book was to gain a better understanding of patient and human health professional relationship.
Amidst the reading, researching, and revising I’ve been quite busy (sleep has been a little deprived at times), no complaints here however. This has been a wonderful experience and I know its going to affect (positively) my career choices. In addition to the hope that I will be able to publish this study when it’s complete, I’ll know the process for future opportunities.
Friday, January 29, 2010
Location, location, location!
I first called the phone number on the website for Vyew (800-594-4559)...I called and no one was home. You can not speak to a person. A voice says you've reached the number for Vyew, however you have to leave a number. I decided not to do this because the recording didn't say what department I have. I may be calling the wrong department...it felt like a waste of time. So I moved on...
I spoke to Shawn at Webex (888-469-3239), he was friendly but I knew just as much before I spoke to him then I did after. I explained to him that I needed a web meeting room to conduct a forum for a course project. He asked how many people and I estimated at 10 to 15 (I'll explain more below). He said there was a free trial period (which I had seen on the website) otherwise the price would be $49.99/mo (which is also on the website). I said I had noticed a lot of other options, does it look like I would need anything else besides the email, he said he didn't think so. I then asked exactly how does this work (this part was not on the website)...he explained an email would be sent with the web rooms link to the participants explaining the date and time of the forum. I asked if it was possible to have the service for one month and he said I could do that.
After calling I really felt like I didn't know enough to decide where to turn or more specifically which sites I should turn to seeking a web conference or forum room. However I found a site on line that gives an independent opinion of various sites that offer web conference rooms (http://www.webconferencing-test.com/en/webconference_home.html). After reviewing this site I plan on taking the weekend to look at the top five sites and call them on Monday. My goal is to have a decision by the end of next week.
This web forum idea came out of the thought to draw the most honest and open opinion of where medicine professionals believe our current relationship is, how to best improve the relationship, and what the impact has on controlling zoonotic disease. A web conference room would be pooling medicinal professionals both by their location and later a conference with those speaking most on the subject with professionals from other areas. I realize this is a big endeavor and I have only a few months to complete it. So I would like to have the first forum in the beginning of March and the last by the end of March or very beginning of April.
Essentially this entry is boiled down to this....I've done some research and decided I need to do more (forget making a long story short, huh). Hopefully when you read my entries from next week you'll see I've made a decision.
~Meresa
Sunday, January 24, 2010
Week Two...More ideas to come...
- Vyew Instant Workplaces (http://vyew.com/site/): Vyew caught my attention mainly because of the awesome review they received from PC world. They not only offer a means to have the forum, but the information can be kept through their server to be later reviewed. Many formats can be used for conducting the forum such as web cam and voice over IP, however the format I'm interested in is text messaging. I like the idea of being able to keep a formal record of who attended and of what was said. I have to admit their pricing is a little confusing and I'm not exactly sure what I would need and how much it will cost. To get a basic room is free however there's a limit in participants and advertising by the website will be shown during the meeting. I'll be calling their customer service this upcoming week (week of January 25th) to see what their staff recommend.
- Cisco Webex (http://www.webex.com/lpintl/us/sem/online_meetings.htm?CMP=KNC-sem&TrackID=1016574&hbxref=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.google.com%2Fsearch%3Fsourceid%3Dnavclient%26ie%3DUTF-8%26rlz%3D1T4ACGW_en___US347%26q%3DForum%2Bor%2Bmeeting%2Brooms%2Bonline&semid=G14.017.001.online%20meeting&goid=WebexUS_1016574): Cisco is a rather well known company in business services, so that makes me look at what they have to offer very seriously. I don't know a lot about what they are offering, because they don't have as good website as Vyew in explaining their services. Other than the 14 day free trial period they advertise on their website, I'll have to call their customer services representatives to acquire more information.
The forum is a good way to get realtime information from professionals. A survey is a great means, however I do not believe it will get the most honest responses. To have a "room" of professionals sharing the roles, where they believe improvement needs to be made, and a way to document all (so their isn't any confusion of who said what...its formal documentation), will give the clearest, direct, and open information.
This upcoming week I plan on narrowing down the cities to target in my research. The states I'm using were decided on quite awhile ago and include: Texas, California, New York, and Florida. Each of these states offer zoonotic diseases that are unique or more prevalent to them because of their climate, unique ecological challenges, or simply due to the melting pot of communities inside their borders. In addition these four states pretty much make up a good representation of the issues in the rest of the country. The only exception is Hawaii. However there isn't any other state in the United States that has a climate like Hawaii making a focus of that state a poor choice.
The focus in my capstone class this upcoming week is a literature review. This last week the focus was writing the outline for the literature review. To be honest, I do not believe I completed the assignment well and I stumbled across a problem I've had for as long as I can remember. If I think its an extra step (such as creating the outline for upcoming assignment) I have a difficult time doing it. If I can sit down and simply write the paper for example, and the outline isn't necessary I have a difficult time making the outline or what I think of as simplifying the work. This may sound strange but I've noticed this issue with myself in the past. However I was able to review the list I compiled last term for my sources, and they still seem to stand up well; I plan on uploading a copy of the proposal I did for last term so you can see the sources I've chosen.
I'm always keeping my eyes open for more material in the news regarding zoonotic disease and prevention, looking for additional potential sources. In my local newspaper (Ludington Daily News) there was an article from a syndicated columnist (Dr. Gott) titled "Dogs may be culprit in the case of owner's rash (Dr Gott, January 2010)." The woman (a pet owner) that wrote Dr. Gott simply tells of a seeping rash she gets every so often on her arms and ankles that has left her dermatologist stumped as to its cause. Dr. Gott points out about her dogs and the location of the rash that point to the possible of the cause agent being related to her pets. While reading this article it reiterated the lack of information asked by professionals regarding if someone has pets or not and the role their pet may have in transmitting disease or other health conditions to their pet owners. I'm all the more excited about the potential my paper holds.
~Meresa
Dr. Gott (January 23, 2010) "Dogs may be culprit in the case of owner's rash." Ludington Daily News. Shoreline Media Inc.
Friday, January 15, 2010
Introductions
Before being in the Peace Corp my goal was to become a Veterinarian (never changed) and specialize in wildlife and exotics. My more than ten years as a Licensed Wildlife Rehabilitator (Michigan) and having worked with wildlife and exotics in the veterinary setting instilled a passion to contribute to the preservation of native species. The passion is still there however its not as strong as what was provoked during my brief stay in Niger.
Nothing makes something more real such as poverty, until you see it personally. My experience in Niger was sobering. I live in a wonderful country, the United States of America, where even when times are at their worse, I can turn to my government or local organizations. The people in Niger, a country that was labeled as the poorest country in the world by the United Nations in 2007, do not have anyone to turn to but the visiting non-governmental organizations (NGO's). I want to clarify this is not because their government doesn't care about them, the government has little resources to generate a decent means of supporting their people when more than 70% of the country is desert. Its great when NGO's enter into a country and offer aid in some fashion (example. clothing, food, etc.). However Niger is an example of how providing sustainable assistance (example. seeds for crops, livestock, wells, etc) is a measure that would last well beyond the exodus of an NGO. In our country we would also refer to the difference as being a hand out or a hand up.
My capstone project titled "Friend or foe? The working relationship between veterinary medicine and human medicine" is the start to working internationally in sustainable agriculture. You may be reading this and say "How is studying the working relationship between the two professions in the United States going to help you in working internationally?" The one thing I definitely walked away with...poverty will not be ended by one person, one group of people, one culture, and definitely not through the valiant efforts of one profession. We are going to all have to work together. However the leaders will be those in the medical profession (veterinarians and physicians) demonstrating and enabling methods for keeping livestock at their healthiest and crops at their fullest, leading to the annihilation of poverty.
What is the current working relationship between the veterinary and human medicine professions? How effective is the relationship in controlling zoonotic disease? And what measures are recommended (as a result of the collected data) between the two professions to enable both in zoonotic disease prevention?
As you follow my entries you'll see my capstone project materializing. Literature reviews, determining the methodology, submitting a project proposal, data collecting (examining the methods of data collecting), publishing the results, and determining potential zoonotic disease prevention methods are what you will be reading for the next 12 weeks. I hope you'll enjoy the adventure as much as I will!
Meresa Salisbury, LVT